DC Bar
Proud Sponsor of the Organization of Women in International Trade - Badge
Virginia State Bar

FTC Deadlock Clears IonQ’s Acquisition of SkyWater Without Remedy

Andre Barlow

On July 28, 2026, the Federal Trade Commission granted early termination of its Hart-Scott-Rodino review of IonQ Inc.’s approximately $1.8 billion acquisition of SkyWater Technology, Inc. The decision allowed the deal to close without conditions or a consent order. The outcome was not a unanimous determination that the transaction raised no competitive issues. It was the product of a 1-1 split between the Commission’s only two sitting members—Chairman Andrew N. Ferguson and Commissioner Mark R. Meador—on whether short-term vertical concerns warranted a behavioral remedy. Both agreed that a full lawsuit to block the merger would have been an imprudent use of agency resources. With no majority for an order and litigation off the table, early termination was the only remaining path.

The Transaction and Vertical Concerns

IonQ is a developer of quantum computers racing with rivals to achieve the first practical fault-tolerant systems. SkyWater is a U.S.-based semiconductor foundry that fabricates specialized chips and provides development services for quantum-computing companies, including IonQ and several of its competitors. The deal creates a vertically integrated platform combining quantum hardware development with domestic fabrication capacity.

Staff’s investigation identified classic vertical risks: (1) the merged firm’s ability and incentive to delay or withhold SkyWater’s foundry services from IonQ’s rivals (particularly those with ongoing projects, given high switching costs and limited near-term capacity), and (2) IonQ’s potential access to rivals’ competitively sensitive technical information held at SkyWater. These concerns were especially salient in a strategic technology race involving national-security and commercial applications, where the Administration has prioritized U.S. leadership through investments and executive action.

Chairman Ferguson’s Position

Chairman Ferguson stated that he did not prefer the early-termination outcome. He concluded that the evidence gave him “reason to believe” the vertical merger “may be substantially to lessen competition” in the short term, even while likely producing procompetitive efficiencies and innovation benefits over the longer term as additional domestic foundry capacity comes online. He favored a negotiated behavioral order that would have addressed the short-term risks while preserving the deal’s longer-term advantages. That order reportedly included non-discrimination commitments, information firewalls, switching assistance for affected customers, monitoring, and prior-notice provisions for future foundry acquisitions. He viewed an outright challenge as overkill because it would have blocked both the short-term risks and the benefits of vertical integration. In the absence of a majority for the order, he concluded the Commission should “get out of the way and permit the merger to close so that the likely benefits for competition and innovation may swiftly be realized.”

Commissioner Meador’s Position

Commissioner Meador reached the opposite conclusion on the merits. He found the available evidence insufficient to demonstrate that the transaction “may be substantially to lessen competition,” and instead viewed it as procompetitive or competitively neutral. He identified four principal reasons: (1) any hypothetical foreclosure share fell well below the 50% threshold the 2023 Merger Guidelines treat as presumptively substantial, and below the 30–40% levels courts have typically required in exclusive-dealing cases; (2) SkyWater was not a “must-have” input, given the diversity of quantum hardware modalities, alternative foundries, and national-laboratory capacity; (3) the foreclosure risk was decidedly short-term; and (4) substantial federal investment under the current Administration is expanding the domestic quantum ecosystem and reducing structural dependencies. He therefore could not support what he characterized as regulatory intervention into a dynamic innovation market.

Implications

The IonQ-SkyWater clearance illustrates the practical consequences of a two-commissioner FTC. A majority is required to issue a complaint or accept a consent order. When the two members disagree on whether the facts support a reason to believe that competition may be substantially lessened—and both view full litigation as imprudent—the transaction proceeds without remedy. The case also provides a detailed public window into how the current Commissioners approach vertical mergers involving specialized inputs in strategic technologies. Ferguson was prepared to use behavioral relief to manage short-term foreclosure and information risks while preserving longer-term efficiencies and national-policy benefits. Meador applied a higher evidentiary threshold focused on foreclosure share, the existence of alternatives, the temporal scope of the concern, and the broader competitive and policy environment. Both rejected ideological hostility to vertical integration and agreed that an outright block was unwarranted. For parties contemplating vertical combinations in concentrated or strategic input markets, the statements underscore that close factual questions can produce different outcomes under the same record, and that a split Commission can clear a deal that one member would have conditioned.

Andre Barlow

abarlow@dbmlawgroup.com

Aerial view of Washington DC cityscape from Arlington Virginia USA.

Contact Us

Fill out the form or call us at (202) 589-1834 to schedule your consultation.